Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Tax cut compromise

So after an election whose primary substantive message was "get back on the wagon", we have a compromise in which co-dependent Rs and Ds agree to buy each other lots of their favorite drinks.

One can have a serious discussion about the scientific case for more spending now versus starting the fiscal belt-tightening that must come sooner or later, but in strictly political terms, this is both parties giving voters the finger.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Assorted links

1. The Onion mocks high speed rail.

2. Top ten Republican thinkers? All but two of these - George Will and Newt Gingrich - are just pundits and/or TV personalities, not thinkers in the sense of public intellecturals. And the rest make for a rather sad list.

3. Kim Jong Il managing by walking around and looking at things. Perhaps he should write an airport book to generate some much-needed foreign currency?

4. Red light cameras illustrate the principal-agent problem between voters and their elected representatives.

5. More TSA wear.

Hat tip on #3 to Lars Skipper

Gelman on regression practice

A fine post from Andrew Gelman on important rules for regression practice.

You'll see some comments from ECONJEFF as well.

Mankiw on UI

A thoughtful post from Mankiw on Unemployment Insurance (UI).

He leaves out a couple of bits that are relevant to the current discussion. The first is that one additional benefit of UI centers on increasing the quality of job matches. Severely credit constrained workers without much in the way of assets will make bad job matches very quickly in the absence of UI and that has some costs for the economy in terms of forgone output and later job switching.

The second is that my understanding of the optimal UI literature is that it does have one fairly robust finding, which is that UI benefits should decline with spell length. This finding pops out fairly quickly from a model in which individuals have heterogeneous tastes for leisure. Among those with long spells, individuals with a strong taste for leisure are over-represented because the dynamic selection process weeds out those who do not like leisure earlier in the spell. As the optimal UI payment is decreasing in taste for leisure, so also is it decreasing in spell length.

The third is that there are dynamic issues here. We are setting up expectations for the next recession. This increases the impact of current extensions on future budgets.

I think I would be inclined to do the following in terms of an extension:

(1) Don't call the checks UI. Call them "Temporary Aid to the Long Term Unemployed". This makes it clear that they are welfare and not social insurance via the parallel to Temporary Aid to Needy Families. It also, hopefully, reduces expectations regarding future, milder, recessions.

(2) Following the optimal UI literature, reduce the replacement rate so that payments decline a bit. One could even think about dropping the replacement rate business altogether (along the theme that this is not a social insurance program and not really UI) and tying the payments to demographics instead. The cost of that is a whole bunch of bureaucracy that it would be hard to do quickly (and for which UI offices are likely ill-suited), so I guess I prefer just reducing the replacement rate a bit for practical reasons. Similar practical concerns arise with otherwise reasonable ideas like making people with family incomes above some level ineligible for the extended benefits.

(3) Attach some time-consuming job search requirements along the lines of those imposed in some states under the Worker Profiling and Reemployment Services System (WPRS). What I have in mind are the sorts of things Kentucky was doing when the data were generated for the Black, Smith, Berger and Noel (2003) American Economic Review paper. These sorts of required services are a two-fer. Based on the results in BSBN, they chase some people off UI who should not really be there. For the people who should be there, they may help them get a job by providing them with job search skills or simply by giving them a needed pep talk or kick in the pants. In this context, it may be useful to include some of the sorts of counseling services sometimes offered to high-wage union workers displaced from contracting industries and designed to help them adjust their wage expectations down to something closer to the value of their marginal product.

Like Greg, I think the petition is telling us about the normative views of those who sign it as well as their positive views, but there is some of both, as the statement of views at the start of the petition makes clear. I should note in full disclosure that the list of petition signers includes several friends of mine.

Sunday, December 5, 2010

Richard Epstein

Nick Gillespie from reason interviews law professor Richard Epstein.

There's not as much meat here as in Epstein's law school talk that I blogged about a few weeks ago, but it is still good fun.

Subject line of the week

I received an email on Friday with the subject line:

"sorry for multiple e-mails - got a job"

I still laugh every time I think about it.

Just to clarify for the students who read this: yes, I am very busy, and yes, I get a lot of emails. But emails telling me that you got a job offer do not need to be apologized for!

Really.

And congrats to the job-offer-getting student, who got the exact job she wanted.

Washington 35, Washington State 28

Washington wins the Apple Cup 35-28 and is off to a bowl after seven seasons without one. Chris Polks was the real star with 284 yards rushing. But credit to the Cougars: they played much, much better than last year. This one really shouldn't have gone down to the final minute, but it did.

Washington also finishes third (!!!) in the PAC-10 with a 5-4 conference record.